Welcome to LivingPianos.com. I’m Robert Estrin. Today we’re continuing our multi-part series on How to learn and play Clementi’s Sonatina in C Major, Opus 36, No. 1. This article focuses on the second movement, a lyrical contrast to the vibrant first and third movements. More than just learning the notes, we’ll explore how to elevate your performance to a high expressive level.
This is the second in a four-part series, which includes an in-depth look at each of the three movements, as well as a complete performance of the work.
A Stark Contrast from the First Movement
The second movement is a complete departure from the bright energy of the first. Where the first movement features crisp staccato, lively fingerwork, and dynamic contrasts, the second movement introduces a gentler, more introspective mood and tonal palette.
An important tip when performing this piece: between movements, don’t lift your hands from the keyboard. If you do, audiences may mistakenly think the piece has ended and applaud prematurely. The three movements together create a greater artistic impact than each one alone. So keep your hands on the keys, transition directly, and let the music flow seamlessly.
The Hidden Challenge of the Second Movement
Though slower and more lyrical, this movement is arguably the most difficult of the three. Why? Primarily because of the balance between the hands. Here’s the issue: high notes on the piano fade more quickly than low notes. On top of that, the left hand often plays two or three times more notes than the right. If you play both hands at equal volume, the melody in the right hand will be lost under the busier bass. To correct this, the left hand must be extremely light, almost feather-like. Keep your fingers close to the keys and use minimal effort. In contrast, the right hand melody requires more weight from the arm to sustain notes and create a singing line.
The Importance of Tempo
The movement is marked Andante, which means ‘a walking pace.’ It should feel relaxed but not drag. Playing it too slowly causes the melody to lose shape and energy. A slightly quicker tempo helps the melody connect more naturally, especially given the fading quality of the higher notes.
Breathing Life Into the Phrases
All the phrases in this movement — and in most lyrical classical music — need to rise and fall dynamically, just like the natural inflection of speech or breathing. Without this shaping, the music sounds robotic. Think of each phrase as a musical breath: a gentle swell followed by a natural relaxation. This gives your playing vitality and emotional impact. To achieve this, use your arm weight in the right hand and transfer it smoothly from note to note. Don’t try to calculate the volume of each finger. Instead, feel the line as a whole and let it breathe.
Simplifying the Trill
There is a trill early in the movement, and it’s a common stumbling block. Don’t feel compelled to play a large number of notes. Instead, simply play two notes for each triplet eighth in the left hand. This sounds elegant and musical without overcomplicating your technique. Later, if you gain confidence, you can embellish further by playing more notes. But keep it simple at first. Trills offer creative license. They don’t require a set number of notes. What matters is musicality and flow and to decide how many notes you will play.
Connecting Repeated Notes
A particularly challenging aspect of this movement is dealing with repeated notes, which are hard to play legato since the same key must fully release before being played again. To solve this, you must change fingers on repeated notes and lift previously played fingers high. For example, going from finger 5 to 4 on the same note, the 5th finger must lift high above the key before repeating the note. If the previous finger doesn’t lift sufficiently, the connection will be broken and sound detached. This technique allows you to create a smooth, singing line, which is crucial for expressive playing.
No Pedal Required
It’s possible — and preferable — to play this entire movement without using the pedal. This forces you to develop finger control and clarity. The pedal can easily muddy the texture and mask weaknesses in legato technique. By learning to control your phrasing and legato with your hands alone, you’ll develop a much more refined touch, and a deeper connection to the music.
Phrasing and Rhythmic Nuance
When you encounter dotted rhythms, be mindful of their precise placement. For instance, a sixteenth note following a dotted eighth should not fall exactly halfway between the beat. It should come slightly earlier. Getting this rhythmic placement correct adds grace and authenticity to your playing. Incorrect placement can make the phrase sound awkward or stiff.
Playing Repeated Notes in Thirds Smoothly
In one passage, you encounter repeated notes in thirds, making finger changes impossible. Instead, make sure you stay close to the keys and let the keys return fully between repetitions. This technique is subtle but essential. It allows you to maintain smoothness even when technical options are limited.
Shaping the Final Phrases
Toward the end of the movement, you’ll find phrases that taper off dynamically. Don’t rush these just because the measure “looks” shorter. Each measure takes the same amount of time, regardless of how many notes it contains. Also, don’t let the final notes stick out. Begin with enough sound on the longer notes so you can naturally decrescendo into the phrase ending. If the long note is too soft to start with, you won’t be able to taper off, and the last note will pop out unnaturally.
Thumb Repetition and Legato
At one point, you’ll have to play a sixth interval with the thumb on two consecutive notes. Since it’s impossible to connect a thumb to itself, don’t try to force a legato between those bottom notes. Instead, connect the top notes and let the bottom be slightly detached. That way, the melody still flows. This is a common technique in piano playing — connecting what you can, and releasing what you must, while maintaining the illusion of complete legato of all notes.
Dynamics: It’s About Tone, Not Volume
Even in soft passages, you can use generous arm weight to produce a full, projecting tone. Piano doesn’t mean lifeless or weak. If you’ve ever heard a flute or oboe solo marked piano in an orchestra, you know it still carries throughout the hall. The same applies to piano playing: dynamics are relative and expressive, not measured by a decibel meter. So don’t be afraid to use more sound than you think you need. A rich tone is essential to communicating the line, especially in a performance space.
Repeated Techniques Throughout the Movement
Throughout the movement, you’ll encounter repeated note patterns again. Apply the same techniques. Change fingers when possible, lift previously played fingers, and shape the phrase with rise and fall. Eventually, the first theme returns, giving the movement a sense of unity and closure.
Skills You Can Use Across Classical Music
This lyrical second movement offers a wonderful opportunity to develop your expressive playing and technical control. Everything you learn here applies not only to the other movements of this sonatina, but also to a wide range of classical repertoire — from other Clementi works to Mozart, Haydn, Beethoven, and beyond. The principles of balance, phrase shaping, and touch are universal. I hope you find these insights helpful in your own practice. I’m Robert Estrin and this is LivingPianos.com, Your Online Piano Resource.
