Welcome to LivingPianos.com. I’m Robert Estrin. Today, we’re exploring the question: What if Beethoven had YouTube? At first it might seem like a frivolous idea, but there are profound implications here. Beethoven would have had exposure to music from all over the world. What would that have done for his compositions? Composers were so isolated in those days. Sure, they made every effort to learn the great works of others, but with YouTube, we literally have the world’s music in our pockets at the click of our fingers.
Global Access and Musical Innovation
Think about all the other composers around the globe who might have created far greater works if they had been able to hear the masterpieces clustered in Austria and Germany—Mozart, Haydn, Beethoven, and Schubert. Access to all those works could have dramatically reshaped music history. Bach is a key example. He didn’t travel much, but he made an effort to attend concerts by any musicians who came to his home in Leipzig, Germany. Through that effort, he was able to compose in the Italian, English, and French styles, creating phenomenal music.
If you know a lot of Bach’s works, you realize just how unique his Italian concerto is. He also embraced the English and French styles, as you can hear in his Suites. These styles are dramatically different from one another. Imagine the exposure he could have had to Spanish music or the music of the Americas. Even so, he produced fantastic compositions simply by attending concerts and learning from others.
Beethoven and the World of Music
Now imagine Beethoven with access to all the musical styles and cultures around the world. The possibilities are staggering. Composers of his time lived in relative isolation. Franz Schubert was obscure to the world until after his death! You can see a parallel in the early 20th century. Listen to recordings of pre-World War II artists like Rachmaninoff, Hofmann, Paderewski, Levine and other pianists from that age. They all had dramatically different styles from one another. With recordings, musicians could hear each other, and today, everyone can hear everyone, and performances have become more homogenous. Listening to those old recordings, even with the scratchy sound, you can hear individuality that far surpasses the variety of performances today.
More Creativity or More of the Same?
Would the presence of YouTube in Beethoven’s time have created more homogeneity, or would it have inspired the same kind of individuality and variety we hear in Bach? In the 20th century, the Beatles provided a great example of global musical influence. George Harrison studied with Ravi Shankar, the great Indian musician, and you can hear that influence in songs like Within You, Without You. Their music reflects a fusion of styles from around the world.
Creativity or Distraction?
So here is the question I leave you with. If YouTube had existed in Beethoven’s time, would it have sparked more creativity through exposure to new sounds and styles, or would it have led composers to sound more like each other? The answer is unknown, and it is fascinating to ponder. One last thought: if YouTube had been around, would Beethoven have spent too much time doom scrolling and not enough time composing these great works? These are the kinds of questions I think about when imagining this alternate history. Let me know your thoughts about this in the comments here at LivingPianos.com and on YouTube!
Beatles: Within You Without You
Ignacy Paderewski plays “Menuet” in G
Josef Hofmann
Sergei Rachmaninoff
Josef Lhevinne