Tag Archives: how to play piano

I Practiced So Hard My Fingers Bled — Here’s What I Learned


Welcome to LivingPianos.com. I’m Robert Estrin. When I was in high school, I practiced so intensely one summer that my fingernails actually began to detach slightly from my fingers. There was even some blood on the keys. It may sound extreme, but it taught me an important lesson about developing real strength at the piano, and the truth might surprise you.

A Summer at the Mozarteum

I was seventeen years old when I was accepted to study for a summer at the Mozarteum in Salzburg, Austria. This is one of the world’s great music conservatories, located in Mozart’s birthplace. Walking through Salzburg, you feel the weight of musical history and the sense that music is not just an activity, but a way of life.

I arrived with enormous ambition and chose to take on the music of Franz Liszt. This is not music you approach casually. Liszt demands everything from a pianist, including technique, stamina, and physical power. I was determined to rise to the challenge and practiced for hours every day.

When Practice Goes Too Far

What I did not understand at seventeen was how the hands respond when pushed beyond their limits. The practice rooms were small, each with a Bösendorfer grand piano, and I spent long hours working through demanding passages. The music required tremendous finger strength to project melodies over thick textures. Over time, the repeated pressure and friction caused slight separation of the fingernails from the nail beds on several fingers. It was not dramatic, but there was pain and some bleeding. I remember wondering if this was simply part of the process. Did building strength at the piano require that kind of physical sacrifice?

The Truth About Building Strength

The honest answer is no. You do not have to go through that kind of pain. My experience was the result of overwork and practicing far beyond what my hands could handle at the time. That part was avoidable.

However, there is an important truth here. As pianists develop proper technique, there is a natural adjustment that takes place in the fingertips. Proper playing requires rounded fingers, not flat ones. The fingertips, not the nails, must contact the keys. If your nails are too long, or if your fingertips are not yet resilient, the nails can hit the keys, creating a clicking sound and reducing control. Over time, pianists develop small pads at the tips of their fingers, almost like calluses, which allow for better contact and control. As these pads develop, it is not uncommon for the nail to separate slightly from the nail bed. It is part of the body adapting to the demands of proper technique. This is not something to fear. It is a sign of progress when it happens gradually and naturally. What I did wrong was forcing the process too quickly.

Building Strength the Right Way

Strength at the piano is not built through sheer force or endless repetition. It comes from intelligent practice combined with proper recovery. Just like athletes, pianists must balance effort with rest. A sprinter does not run at full speed for hours, and a weightlifter does not push maximum effort continuously. The body needs time to recover and adapt. The same principle applies to piano practice. Instead of playing for long, exhausting stretches, focus on shorter, highly concentrated sessions. Take a difficult passage and work on it with full attention for a few minutes. Then step away. Rest your hands. Return later and repeat the process. This cycle of effort and recovery builds real, lasting strength.

Strength Versus Control

That summer in Salzburg also taught me something deeper. Being surrounded by dedicated musicians showed me that physical strength is only part of the equation. The pianists who stood out were not the ones who played the loudest. They were the ones who played with control. Their powerful moments felt natural and inevitable, not forced.

Strength without control is simply noise.

True power at the piano comes from using the entire mechanism of the body. The arms must be engaged, and the weight of the arms should support the fingers. When you rely only on finger strength, you work against yourself and risk injury. This was exactly my mistake. When arm weight is properly supported by a relaxed wrist, the tone becomes fuller and more resonant, and the hands remain healthy.

A Better Path Forward

So, do you have to bleed to develop strength at the piano? Absolutely not. But the experience taught me a lesson I have never forgotten. The path to power at the piano is through intelligence, not punishment. Practice with focus and intention, and allow time for recovery. That is how you develop both strength and control.

If you have questions about piano technique or practice, I encourage you to explore further and continue refining your approach. You can also visit LivingPianos.com to discover more resources and insights into the world of pianos.

Are These the Pianos of the Future?

Welcome to LivingPianos.com. I’m Robert Estrin. The piano is one of the most enduring instruments ever created, and in many ways it has remained remarkably consistent for well over a century. But that may be starting to change. Today, I’d like to explore three innovations that could reshape what a piano can be: smaller keys, foldable designs, and aftertouch. And later, I’m going to show you one of my two prototype modular piano systems that delivers a virtual concert grand experience in a completely different way. These are not gimmicks, nor are they replacements for traditional pianos, but they raise fascinating questions about where piano design is headed, what problems are being solved, and what the piano of the future might look like.

Smaller Keys: Expanding Accessibility

Let’s start with smaller keys. The standard piano keyboard was established a very long time ago, and pianists have largely accepted it as fixed ever since. But of course, hands are not all the same size. As a student, I struggled to develop strength and to play large chords effectively because of my hand size. It wasn’t until years later, working with students who had larger hands, that I realized how significant this difference can be. Some pianists are able to master certain repertoire much more easily simply because of their physical advantage.

For many players, standard-sized keys can make intervals like octaves and tenths, as well as big chords and wide stretches, difficult or even impossible. This is where smaller or scaled keyboards become so compelling. This isn’t about making the piano easier. It’s about making it more accessible. If a different keyboard size allows a pianist to play with greater comfort, less strain, and more freedom, it opens the door to more repertoire and a more natural playing experience.

Foldable Pianos: Rethinking Portability

Next, let’s consider foldable pianos. One of the piano’s most obvious limitations is its size and weight. A concert grand is enormous, and even an upright is extremely difficult to move. The idea of a foldable piano is really about rethinking the physical form of the instrument. I’m not referring to inexpensive folding keyboards you might see online, which are not true substitutes for pianos. Rather, I’m talking about the possibility of a serious instrument with a satisfying action and full musical potential in a form that is dramatically easier to transport.

This could be a game changer for performers, teachers, and traveling musicians. When traveling by car, bringing along a digital piano is manageable. But flying with a high-quality keyboard instrument is another matter entirely. Personally, when I’m on vacation and have some free time, I want access to a piano! If there were a high-quality digital instrument that could fit in carry-on luggage, I would be first in line to get one. It’s a radical idea, but also a very practical one.

Aftertouch: A New Dimension of Expression

Now let’s turn to aftertouch, something many traditional pianists may never have encountered. This concept comes from the world of electronic instruments. On an acoustic piano, once the hammer strikes the string, your control over that note is essentially set. Aftertouch changes that by responding to pressure applied after the key is already depressed. This means a note can continue to be shaped even after it has begun to sound. Depending on the instrument, that additional pressure can influence vibrato, dynamics, tonal color, or other expressive elements.

I remember playing a Yamaha GS-1 in the early 1980s. It was an advanced 88-key synthesizer with touch sensitivity and polyphonic aftertouch. That meant you could apply pressure to individual keys after the notes were sounding and bring out different voices independently. The level of control was remarkable. Will every pianist want this? Probably not. But it does suggest a future in which keyboard expression extends beyond the initial attack in ways that acoustic pianos cannot offer.

What These Innovations Suggest

So what do these three ideas point to? To me, they highlight three important directions: greater accessibility, greater portability, and expanded expressive potential through hybrid and digital technologies. None of this suggests that the concert grand piano is going away. Far from it. The acoustic grand remains one of the most extraordinary instruments ever created. However, the definition of what a “piano” is may continue to expand. With advancements in player technology, performances can take place simultaneously on multiple instruments in different locations. You can even experience your favorite pianist playing on your own piano. The possibilities are extraordinary.

We will almost certainly see more hybrid instruments. Alternative key sizes may become more widely accepted. Perhaps one day, concert halls will offer multiple keyboard sizes to accommodate different pianists. We may also see entirely new physical designs and instruments that preserve the essence of piano playing while adding capabilities earlier generations never imagined.

A Glimpse Into Modular Piano Systems

This brings me back to the prototype modular piano systems I mentioned earlier, which are designs I personally developed. What excites me about these is their ambitious goal: to create a virtual concert grand experience in a completely new form. These systems are not intended to replace traditional concert grands. Instead, they offer a fascinating new direction, allowing pianists to enjoy a highly sophisticated playing experience with greater flexibility and adaptability. Imagine having the experience of a 9-foot concert grand anywhere, even in a small apartment, and even being able to play with headphones.

As you consider these developments, think about what they represent. Not just new products or novelties, but a broader vision of where piano design may be headed. The future of the piano may not be defined by a single innovation, but by several paths evolving at once. Some will remain niche, others may become mainstream, and a few may fundamentally change how people think about the instrument.

What do you think? Which of these innovations interests you most: smaller keys, foldable designs, aftertouch, or modular hybrid systems?

And if you want to learn more about pianos and hybrid instruments, visit us at LivingPianos.com, Your Online Piano Resource.

How Fast Can You Name These Classical Masterpieces?

Welcome to LivingPianos.com. I’m Robert Estrin. Today I have something a little different and a lot of fun for you. In this video, I put your ears to the test with a musical guessing game. I play short excerpts from some of the most famous classical piano works ever written, and your challenge is to identify each piece as quickly as possible. Some may be instantly recognizable from just a handful of notes, while others might take a few more seconds before everything clicks into place.

This is more than just a trivia game. It is a wonderful way to sharpen your listening skills and discover how deeply these great works are etched into your musical memory. You might surprise yourself by recognizing a piece from its harmony, rhythm, or even just its texture before the main theme appears. See how many you can name within ten seconds, keep score if you like, and share your results in the comments. I would love to hear which ones you knew right away and which ones kept you guessing.

Let us know how you did on this listening test!

Leave comments about pieces you would like full tutorials on.

Here are the pieces heard in the recording:

ANSWERS

The Shocking Truth About Piano Storage

Welcome to LivingPianos.com. I’m Robert Estrin. If you are considering putting a piano into storage, this is something you absolutely need to think through carefully. I have seen this scenario play out time and time again, and it can end in a way most people never expect.

Climate Control Is Not Optional

People are downsizing, they cannot sell their piano, or they think they may be moving. So what do you do? You find a place to store your piano. If you ever have to do this, make absolutely certain that it is climate controlled storage. I remember having pianos at a storage facility and only later being told that winter was coming and we had better get the pianos out of there. So double check. Make sure the facility is truly climate controlled. This is critical for the health and longevity of your instrument.

The Hidden Costs of Storage

Here is what often happens. You pay month after month to store the piano. Eventually, you have paid so much that you start to wonder what to do next. If you decide to try to sell the piano, good luck. In many storage facilities, pianos are stored on their sides to maximize space. Just to have someone come and look at the piano, you may have to pay hundreds of dollars to have it set up properly. And of course, it will not be tuned because it has been sitting in storage. It can become a nightmare situation for so many people.

What Happens When Payments Stop

Now here is the part that may really shock you. After paying month after month, sometimes for years, people reach a point where they simply stop paying. They do not know what to do with the piano. Often they have already moved, which is why the piano went into storage in the first place. Storage companies will make a good faith effort to contact the owner. But if they cannot reach them, they sell the piano. So after spending hundreds or even thousands of dollars in storage fees, the piano may ultimately be sold by the storage company. I know this for a fact from at least two companies I am intimately familiar with, and this is something that happens on a regular basis.

Think Long Term Before You Store

The lesson for today is simple. Before putting a piano into storage, think long term about your end goal. You do not want to be stuck spending hundreds or thousands of dollars on a piano you may never get out of storage again.

If I can be of any help to you, please reach out to me at Robert@LivingPianos.com. We have many resources available for you here at LivingPianos.com, Your Online Piano Resource.

What Happened to the Greatest Piano Ever Made?

Working My Way Up to Something Special

Over the years, I gradually worked my way up through different pianos. At one point I had a Young Chang 6’1″, and from there I upgraded to a Baldwin L. Each instrument was a step forward, both musically and personally.

Then something unexpected happened. My top piano technician, who was a concert technician, owned an older Mason & Hamlin BB. For those of you who may not know, the BB is a 7-foot grand known for its massive construction and rich tone. Mason & Hamlin pianos have a distinctive depth of sound, and this one was particularly special.

What made it extraordinary was not just the design, but the care it had received. It belonged to a master technician. The regulation and voicing were superb. Everything about the instrument felt refined and responsive. When he decided to move away, he asked me to sell the piano for him. The moment I played it, I knew I wanted it myself. So I sold my piano and bought the Mason & Hamlin. I truly believed I had found the ultimate instrument.

An Offer I Did Not Expect

Not long after that, a concert pianist came in looking for a piano for a friend. At the time, I had a Baldwin L for sale. He tried it and liked it. Then he sat down at my Mason & Hamlin. I told him it was not for sale. He understood, but he kept playing it anyway.

A few days later, he returned and played both pianos again. This time, he made me an offer to purchase both instruments. It was not an easy decision. The Mason & Hamlin was supposed to be my piano. But the offer was significant, and I reluctantly agreed.

Almost immediately, I felt what you might call “seller’s remorse.” I realized that if I ever wanted something equal or better, I would have to look for a 9-foot concert grand. So that is exactly what I did.

Searching for the Ultimate Concert Grand

I brought my technician with me as we searched far and wide for the right instrument. At one point, I even purchased a 9-foot Baldwin in San Francisco. We brought it back and worked on it extensively. It was a fine piano, but it was not quite the extraordinary instrument I was hoping to find.

Then we discovered a Baldwin SD-10 concert grand in the San Fernando Valley. This is a 9-foot concert grand and one of the great American pianos. From the first notes, it was clear this was something very special. My technician told me it was one of the two or three finest pianos he had ever encountered, and he had worked on countless concert instruments. I absolutely loved that piano.

A Piano That Inspired Pianists

We used that Baldwin SD-10 for a concert series, and pianists who performed on it consistently praised it. Many told me it was the best piano they had ever played. It had power, warmth, and remarkable control across the entire range of the keyboard. It was everything I had hoped to find.

A Change of Circumstances

At the time, we were in a loft with 19-foot ceilings, and the piano filled the space beautifully. However, when we moved to a smaller location, it became clear that the instrument was simply too powerful for the room. It was more piano than the space could comfortably handle.

After much thought, I decided to put it up for sale. There was strong interest from around the country. Two different concert organizations were seriously considering purchasing it, and we even discussed the possibility of my performing a dedication recital when the piano was installed. It seemed like the perfect way to pass along such a remarkable instrument.

An Unexpected Buyer

Because those organizations needed board approvals, the process took time. Meanwhile, one Sunday afternoon, an elderly couple came in from the desert. They had seen the piano listed online and wanted to see it in person.

The gentleman sat down at the piano and played just one thing. He stood up and said, “I’ll take it.”

The one piece he played on that piano was Chopsticks!

Where It Ended Up

After all the performances, all the praise from accomplished pianists, and all the discussion of concert halls and dedication recitals, the greatest piano I ever owned ended up in a private home in the desert… For Chopsticks. So I have some mixed feelings about the sale of that piano.

So that is what happened to the greatest piano ever made, at least in my experience. If you have your own story about remarkable pianos, share them in the comments here at LivingPianos.com and on YouTube! Thanks again for joining me.

New vs Vintage Steinway: Which Is Better?

Welcome to LivingPianos.com. I’m Robert Estrin. Today we are talking about a seminal question: whether it is better to buy a new Steinway or a vintage Steinway. You might wonder why anyone would buy a 100 year old piano instead of a brand new one. I get this question all the time, and technicians debate it endlessly. Some say old pianos are junk. Others say they do not make them like they used to. So who is right? Let’s break it down.

The Wood Makes a Difference

The first point is the wood. In the 1920s and 1930s, and even earlier, piano makers had access to old growth wood. Today, most woods are plantation grown. Older woods tend to have tighter grain, which produces greater resonance and depth of sound. There are even major challenges now in obtaining Sitka spruce from Alaska, which is protected. This has created a real crisis in sourcing the finest tonewoods that were once commonly available to piano manufacturers.

Hand Building Versus Machines

Another important factor is how pianos are built. Modern pianos rely heavily on CNC machines, which stands for computer numerical control. These machines are incredibly consistent and precise. Vintage pianos, on the other hand, were hand built. Each one has its own individual personality. When you find a good vintage piano, it has a soul that machines simply cannot replicate. That individuality is something many pianists find irresistible.

The Golden Age of Piano Manufacturing

If you go back to the period before World War Two, there were over one thousand piano companies in operation. Only about 300 or 400 of them were full scale manufacturers, with the rest being smaller assemblers or short lived firms. Still, it was the heyday of piano manufacturing in America. Compare that to today, when only a couple of companies are producing perhaps two or three thousand pianos a year. It was truly a different era.

Why Old Pianos Can Be a Problem

Here is where many people get burned. Pianos are not violins. Violins tend to improve with age, but pianos are machines that wear out. Old strings, cracked soundboards, and worn actions mean that many vintage pianos are essentially furniture unless they are properly restored. To unlock the magic, restoration is essential.

The Hybrid Solution

The solution is a hybrid approach. For example, my piano is a Steinway Model S that my grandfather bought for my father in the early 1940s. It was built in the late 1930s, and it has since been completely rebuilt. You get the original rim, the case, and the structural elements that cannot be replaced. If you are lucky, you also retain the original soundboard, which can be resurrected to produce a magnificent tone. All of the action parts can be rebuilt using Steinway or Renner components. Hammers might be from Steinway or Abel, depending on what is most appropriate for that particular piano.

This is why it is critical to work with a rebuilder who truly understands pianos. Not every Steinway performs best with current Steinway parts, even though Steinway now owns Renner. When done correctly, you can install new strings and a new action while preserving the tonal beauty of old growth wood. This approach gives you the stability of a new piano combined with the tone of aged wood. You can hear a beautiful pianissimo and a gorgeous, singing sustain. That is what people mean when they talk about singing wood from old growth forests. You also get tremendous power and a deep bass growl that is hard to find in most new pianos unless you are spending well into six figures on top tier instruments.

What About Consistency?

One advantage of buying a new piano is consistency, and that is generally true. However, new pianos also have a break in period. During the first couple of years, strings stretch, felt parts settle, and everything gradually seats into place. So the real question is whether you can hear the difference. Listen to Asian production pianos. Listen to new Steinways. If you have tried new Steinways, how do you feel they compare to vintage instruments? I would love to hear your thoughts. Leave a comment at LivingPianos.com, we are Your Online Piano Store!

Also see: New Vs. Vintage Steinway – What They DONT’T tell you: